In this episode of The Rewatch Party, Nick and Anthony dive into Little Nicky, the 2000 Adam Sandler comedy about Satan’s lovable, underdog son who’s sent to Earth to bring back his rebellious brothers. The conversation kicks off with Anthony’s obvious enthusiasm for the film, fondly recounting its absurd humor and quirky charm. Nick, however, is less impressed. Right from the start, he admits that Little Nicky doesn’t quite hit the mark for him. With its bizarre plot and Sandler’s goofy performance, Nick finds the film more awkward than entertaining, but Anthony is quick to defend its cult classic status.

As they dig into Sandler’s portrayal of Nicky, the two hosts can’t help but laugh over the character’s distinctive voice, a combination of mumbling and endearing awkwardness that Sandler used throughout the film. Anthony finds it hilarious and memorable, praising Sandler’s commitment to the bit. Nick, on the other hand, thinks the voice comes off as a little forced, suggesting it overshadows the character’s potential. While they don’t quite agree, both hosts acknowledge that Sandler’s performance is a love-it-or-hate-it situation that makes Little Nicky a unique entry in his filmography.

Moving on to the film’s supporting cast, the pair discuss the motley crew of characters, from Mr. Beefy the talking bulldog to Nicky’s demonic brothers, and cameos by the likes of Quentin Tarantino. Anthony feels the ensemble cast is one of the film’s strong suits, bringing unexpected humor and variety to each scene. Nick, however, feels that many of the characters are one-dimensional and rely heavily on gags that lose their charm after the first viewing. Despite this, he admits there’s a certain absurd appeal to the movie’s relentless oddness, even if it isn’t his taste.

In the end, Nick and Anthony agree to disagree on Little Nicky’s rewatchability. Anthony argues that the film’s surreal humor and oddball characters make it a fun, quirky watch that rewards repeat viewings with hidden jokes and details. Nick, on the other hand, believes it’s one of those movies best appreciated once, unless you’re a dedicated Sandler fan. Wrapping up, the two acknowledge that Little Nicky isn’t for everyone, but for fans of Sandler’s boldest comedic choices, it remains a nostalgic, if divisive, trip into his more experimental work.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0185431/