Is EMDR therapy legitimate science or pseudoscientific sham? In this provocative debate, Dr. Roger McFillin challenges Taraleigh Stemler, a certified EMDR practitioner and licensed marriage and family therapist (LMFT), on whether the popular trauma treatment's signature eye movements and bilateral stimulation offer any real benefit, or if exposure therapy—simply facing painful memories—is doing all the heavy lifting. As both clinicians clash over research validity, the "medicalization" of normal emotions, and whether we've created a therapy-dependent culture, this raw conversation exposes the tribal warfare happening within mental health treatment that directly impacts which therapies patients receive.

Chapters

00:00 The Wild West of Psychotherapy

06:01 The EMDR Process Explained

12:03 Challenging the Efficacy of EMDR

18:10 Post-Traumatic Growth: A Different Perspective

23:58 Critique of EMDR's Application

30:01 Comparing EMDR to Other Treatments

38:56 Therapeutic Approaches: EMDR vs. Traditional Methods

46:58 Bilateral Stimulation: A Controversial Tool

55:06 Client Experiences and Observations

01:01:54 The Scope of EMDR: A One-Size-Fits-All Solution?

01:07:04 The Need for Research and Evidence in Therapy

01:15:21 Research and Effectiveness of EMDR

01:23:03 The Importance of Therapeutic Relationships

01:29:55 The Power of Courage in Therapy

RADICALLY GENUINE PODCAST

Dr. Roger McFillin / Radically Genuine Website

YouTube @RadicallyGenuine

Dr. Roger McFillin (@DrMcFillin) / X

Substack | Radically Genuine | Dr. Roger McFillin

Instagram @radicallygenuine

Contact Radically Genuine

Conscious Clinician Collective

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR PARTNERS

15% Off Pure Spectrum CBD (Code: RadicallyGenuine)
10% off Lovetuner click here

—-----------

FREE DOWNLOAD! DISTRESS TOLERANCE SKILLS

Josh Dech is a Holistic Nutritionist and Physician's Consultant who specializes in Crohn's, Colitis, and severe IBS. After successfully reversing over 300 cases of inflammatory bowel diseases—conditions previously deemed incurable—he has collaborated with world-renowned medical experts. As host of "Reversible," a globally top-ranked podcast on gut health, Josh shares his groundbreaking approach with audiences worldwide. He also serves as a medical lecturer at Priority Health Academy, where he educates physicians on holistic strategies for treating gut health issues and inflammatory bowel disease.

The Gut Health Solution Website

RADICALLY GENUINE PODCAST

Dr. Roger McFillin / Radically Genuine Website

YouTube @RadicallyGenuine

Dr. Roger McFillin (@DrMcFillin) / X

Substack | Radically Genuine | Dr. Roger McFillin

Instagram @radicallygenuine

Contact Radically Genuine

Conscious Clinician Collective

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR PARTNERS

15% Off Pure Spectrum CBD (Code: RadicallyGenuine)
10% off Lovetuner click here

—-----------

FREE DOWNLOAD! DISTRESS TOLERANCE SKILLS

After losing her husband Woody to medication-induced suicide, Kim Witczak transformed devastating grief into a powerful mission for drug safety reform. As an FDA Consumer Representative, she has spent two decades fearlessly challenging pharmaceutical industry narratives about antidepressant safety. Recorded on the historic day after RFK Jr.'s confirmation as HHS Secretary and the launch of the Make America Healthy Again commission, Kim shares her vision for restoring human resilience in a culture that has prioritized pills over personal power. Through her story, we discover why true healing requires the courage to feel rather than numb our pain.

Kim Witczak Website
RADICALLY GENUINE PODCAST

Dr. Roger McFillin / Radically Genuine Website

YouTube @RadicallyGenuine

Dr. Roger McFillin (@DrMcFillin) / X

Substack | Radically Genuine | Dr. Roger McFillin

Instagram @radicallygenuine

Contact Radically Genuine

Conscious Clinician Collective

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR PARTNERS

15% Off Pure Spectrum CBD (Code: RadicallyGenuine)
10% off Lovetuner click here

—-----------

FREE DOWNLOAD! DISTRESS TOLERANCE SKILLS