• Murder Of School Teacher Melinda Pleskovic By Daughters’ Boyfriend Jeffrey Scullin | The Motive

  • Sep 24 2022
  • Length: 52 mins
  • Podcast

Murder Of School Teacher Melinda Pleskovic By Daughters’ Boyfriend Jeffrey Scullin | The Motive

  • Summary

  •  police interrogations 


    On the evening of October 23 2017 20 yr old Jeffrey Scullin called 911 in a panic because he had just found his future mother in law, Melinda Pleskovic, bloody on the kitchen floor


    He and Melinda’s husband, Bruce Pleskovic, had just returned to the home they shared with Jeff’s fiancé (their daughter Anna), their young baby girl, and Melinda and Bruce’s disabled adult child Kyle who has Down syndrome and is nonverbal.


    Bruce and Melinda Pleskovic raised their children in the quiet town of Strongsville, OH.


    Melinda was a pillar of the community, working as a teacher and also coaching the women’s varsity soccer team.


    Inexplicably, The Pleskovic’s daughter Anna began dating Jeffrey Scullin while in high school despite not having Lannister looks, money, or charisma -

    After they graduated they got engaged and conceived a daughter. Being a young couple they needed a lot of help.

    Anna worked as a waitress at Applebee’s and Jeff claimed to be doing some part-time work but at the time of the murder he told police he was unemployed. To help out, the Pleskovics offered to let Anna, Jeff, and their baby live in their basement rent-free so they could save up for their own place.


    They all existed like one big happy family and were excitingly planning Anna and Jeff’s wedding. The Pleskovic’s got along well with the easy-going Jeff. 


    Anna and Jeff scheduled their wedding for October 2017.


    Unfortunately, Months after Jeff moved in, weird occurrences started taking place over the Pleskovic’s home.


    Cash started coming up missing after Jeff moved in. Small bills like ones and fives at first. Then larger amounts.


    What was Jeff’s motive ? 911 call and police interrogations plus killer’s confession


    Moms Murder Madness on YouTube 

    Show More Show Less

What listeners say about Murder Of School Teacher Melinda Pleskovic By Daughters’ Boyfriend Jeffrey Scullin | The Motive

Average Customer Ratings

Reviews - Please select the tabs below to change the source of reviews.

In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.