Absolutely fantastic

I’d never read the book before and l just loved this so much. Laura Purcell is brilliant. The story had me gripped until the last word. The performances were brilliant and I’m just knocked out by how good this is. Thank you!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Highly enjoyable gothic novel.

Really enjoyed the voice acting , loved the vivid imagery used by the author. Her description of opening locks, and the physical effect of fear on the body was stellar! A great listen.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Eerily good...

This book will give you the creeps! But kind of in a good way!
The narration by Katie Scarfe is really quite good. She brings the characters to life.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Proper creepy.

Genuinely creepy book. The author has taken traditional 1800’s horror and made it more original with a little more gore and shock factor. I got the creeps walking through my dark house after reading.. “Ssshhhk ssshhhk!” The best part was the story for the most part was unpredictable with great twists. Finally the audio performance was great. Read it!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Thoroughly enjoyable

An excellent story and well performed, but the recording is very quiet. I had to jack my volume up significantly.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

The Silent Companions

Slow to start but did get interesting with a cracker twist at the end- glad I hung in there

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A disappointing gothic

The premise of the novel has everything you would want in a Gothic novel. Isolated mansion in winter? Check. Oppressive atmosphere fueled by the weather? Check. Heroine's battling darkness by themselves? Check.

But what Purcell promises in her blurb is not seen in the text at all, except through glimpses of prose that does nothing to endear the reader to her protagonist. I was surprised to see that Purcell, a woman, wrote female characters who were either two-dimensional, or unfavorable. For example, the main character, Elsie, despite being from a working class background, is so haughty and judgmental on every other female character in the text! Not only their actions but perhaps more unforgiving, their appearance too.

Similarly, the vilification of the 'gypsies' along with the liberal use of the slur was surprising. And rather than Purcell make a comment about the prejudices of the time, she seems to revel in them. With the murder of innocent Romani characters left unpunished and as a loose end by the novel's conclusion. The monsters themselves were underwhelming, and at the end, I found myself rooting for them over the heroine.

Scarfe does a pretty good job at trying to get listeners to sympathise with otherwise very unsympathetic characters. Her dialogue of different characters, especially the servants though, does nothing to endear us to Elsie who's internal monologue at times is so ignorant that you forget she's from a working class background. And then Purcell reminds you again, and you wonder if the author even likes the character she's created. And if not, why should we?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Don’t bother. Convoluted and contrived.

This was painful to get through, and my hopes of it being worthwhile in the end weren’t realised. It meanders on through a ridiculous plot which ultimately is not explained at all, and features what seems presently to be the usual plot devices of hysterical women and abuse recollections. Too much is revealed in a rush at the end, but still no real explanation of the whole basis of the story. I still don’t know what if anything is supposed to have happened in the final line of the book. Don’t bother.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great story & writing but not scary

I very much enjoyed this book, however do not expect to be scared if you are a big thriller/ horror reader. Performance and voice was great and the story is very well written. I just didn’t find it scary as other reviews had suggested. I did predict the end twist fairly early on in the book which made the end underwhelming. However I do recommend this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The silent companion

A good old ghost story with a nice twist at the end. I definitely think it could have been a bit scarier and more of a rounded off ending but I still think a great read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!