its ok...

its a part 1. the more intesting stuff is in the next one. the think this alittle too talergaft in it. people are dum..
plats and plaits are not the same!.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

This series WAS so good

This series WAS so good, yes it had a few niggles such as often repeating information we know well from previous books, throughout the series she goes through extreme trials, takes on leadership roles and yet still acts very immature. Freida is only a year or two younger than Emily and yet up until the last book, she is made out as if she's a 12 year old kid, and finally, why on earth would anyone think it a good idea to introduce gun powder and weaponry. With the exception of agricultural use, I can't think of anything positive that its introduction brought to our world.

Ok that's quite a lot but we are up to the 13th book. Up until this book I have really enjoyed all them, binge-listening one after another, but this book is full of the filler we already know and its boring, nothing is happening. I will listen to the next book in the hope it gets back to the ever-changing, interesting tale, after all at $15 per book for very short stories, they aren't exactly cheap.

BTW, I get the feeling she would be far better off steering clear of relationships with men, she seems much happier with women, she would be better off being in a relationship with Freida.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Don’t normally write a review

But this time felt I should, there were times through this story, I became frustrated with Emily 😱😱😱how could she not pick up what was wrong with Freda until so late in the story, and how could she be so wishy washy with her, when she was obviously needing severe disciplining for her own good 😥😥 I hope she picks up her game, and finds her brain cells, I have spent a lot of money so far on these books, and was enjoying them until this one, I am off to listen to the next, will let you know, if she finds her mojo, and I continue getting the rest.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Highly recommended

Continuation of Emily’s life in the nameless lands. Fantastic storytelling. Recommend the series to all.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

love it

loved this book. it left me wanting more and I can't wait for the next one.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Performed well, no real content

I enjoyed the performance, after listening to the last 12 books I really don't want to quit the series now, but nothing really happens in this story. She goes to school and has trouble with her friends until right near the end when there is a fight.
Certainly disappointed after the previous stories in the series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

No conclusion

I sometimes have problems with males writing as females, there is a slightly skewed understanding which makes it jarr on the mind. This book was so convoluted that it lost coherence. I skipped much, the only one I have done this with so far. Also there was no resolution at the end. So disliking this I am not sure I will bother with the next book. Also why would any female introduce gun powder. Totally bizarre in my mind the other things yes. Also the total disrespect for education system. It has many failings, though a lot are imposed by a bureaucracy, that drains the souls of educators with totally unrealistic and incredibly heavy work loads. Not a fan of this book. His other books in the series have been intriguing and I enjoyed them this was just annoying.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!