Great Insights and Options

When nearly finish I wrote Part A:

Right now feel rather despondent with respect to the future of Israel, of Judaism and of the world.
Tal has great insights into the state of Jewry in the Diaspora as well as Israel and the state of Israel's continued ability to prevent its own demise. He very powerfully sums up the serious complexity and granularity of the people and the State and the increasing and very sobering signs of their demise.
This book makes it ever more clear that both Israel and the world need to hold their breath for Mashiach. There is no other long term solution it would seem.
Tal explains that their are really 4 significant and very distinct groups of people in Israel and with the Diaspora which is very much concentrated in the USA, and also increasingly distinct and separate, a total of 5 groups that will ultimately determine the long term fate of Judaism, the Jewish people and Israel.
In summary, these groups are the

1) The theocrats (the Ultra-Orthodox in Israel who have significant political power but do next to nothing to defend Eretz Israel which is surrounded by enemies intent on her demise). Through their rabbinic rulings they are also increasingly rejecting, separating and isolating the other groups
2) The Territorialists, those Jews who have populated Judea and Samaria, and the other Territories that are 'disputed' and that require a very significant budget to defend. This group at least is very supportive of Israel (as most are the Zionists and therefore have a strong sense of loyalty to the State of Israel and are willing to defend it). So while they are over-represented in the Israeli Defence Forces, as a group they are a net drain on the economy of the State.

3) The Secularists (who mainly live in Tel Aviv) are the true backbone of the economic and defensive support of Israel, though their loyalty is being increasingly challenged as the Theocrats continue to disenfranchise them.

4) The Fourth Israel are those Israelis; Jews, Arabs and others who are struggling for economic survival and who are not therefore able to significantly support the State of Israel and who may not even share the visions of any of the other three groups.
5) The Diaspora Jews (mostly American Jews) are increasingly off-side with all of these groups in Israel, even the Securalists and are in rapid decline as well because of factors such as inter-marriage so that their financial, logistic and even physical support of Israel continues to decline.
Tal is able to paint a clear picture of the diverse nature of the Jewish people today and of the complex and deteriorating nature of Judaism as well.
It is a bleak and scary picture - for a country and people chosen to be a light to the nations, the future extinction of the State of Israel would clearly appear to be antithetical to HaShem's plans for humanity. Yet it could also demonstrate unequivocally that we need Mashiach to step into this bleak portent and finally bring into full bloom the Great Day of Redemption.

Part B having finished the book:
Tal Keinan has some great ideas and proposals to 'save' Judaism and the Jewish people from a potential extinction over the next 2-3 generations.
I get where he is coming from as a non-religious person who does not believe in Yehovah and yet who sees much value in his tribe that were chosen by Yehovah to be a light to the rest of the world. Keinan sees the 'Light' but not the Giver of the 'Light'.
His passion and sincerity are to be admired and his proposals are definitely worthy of serious reflection and some attempt at implementing, but I fear Keinan will remain unsatisfied by how little his tribe overall appears to hear his call or has any great desire to heed it.

But Yehovah is not and never will be beaten, His plan will bear fruit; His People will live on; His Israel will remain and His Maschiach will bring redemption to Israel, the Jewish People and the entire world. Baruch HaShem!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!